Total Pageviews

Wednesday, December 14, 2011

Shelichos- What exactly is BiMachshava?

Further discussing Shelichos, we learned that we can't derive Shelichos in Gerushin/Kiddushin from Teruma because Teruma is BiMachshava. BiMachshava means you can do it with a thought process, meaning that it requires less action that Gerushin/Kiddushin, so we weren't able to derive those two from Teruma. But what exactly is BiMachshava? It doesn't necessarily make any sense? Thankfully, we have Rashi around. Rashi explains to us that by BiMachshava, one can look at a portion of his crop and think, "This is my Teruma and now I can't eat it." Note: This is later seen in Korban Pesach, where somebody can look at a lamb and think "That is my Korban Pesach." So, my question is, what exactly does it mean that you can just "think" and do the Mitzva. Since when can a simple thought determine how a Mitzva is done? How much thought is required, and how can you measure it? Is there a certain amount of Kavana needed? And what other Mitzvos, other than Teruma and Korban Pesach, can be done through BiMachshava? These are good discussion questions, and hopefully y'all will be able to answer in the comments below...

1 comment:

  1. Gabe, these are very intriguing questions. The mitzvah of terumah is not done 100 percent bimachshavah. Bimachshava is just a factor of terumah that the gemara brings in order to compare and contrast in order to derive. There are thoughts that are invloved in terumah. For example, when somebody tells someone else to gather terumah and he does not know how much to gather, he needs to THINK about how much the ba'al habayit would give. I do not think that it is trying to say that once you think, you fullfill the mitzvah; however, it is saying that thinking plays a role in the mitzvah.

    ReplyDelete